Potato Salad Makeover

IMG_9211The heat of summer begs for water activities and picnics, requiring lighter fare and old standards.  For many that may be hot dogs, burgers, chicken or other grilled meats but I am always more focused on the sides.  Seasonal fruits and vegetables are at their peak flavor right now and the possibilities are limited only by your imagination.  Among my favorites are sweet corn, new potatoes, green beans and tomatoes.  I think most people would agree that nothing rivals the taste of tomatoes, vine ripened and freshly picked.  The heirloom varieties top my “best flavor” list.

IMG_9069But then there is sweet corn.  Available for such a short window, the hunt is always on for the vendor with the freshest and sweetest selection.  I grew up eating corn on the cob that was  shucked and then boiled way too long, but today my preferred method of preparation is grilling.  The caramelization of the sugars and the char from the fire is near culinary perfection.  IMG_7668New potatoes are  yet another taste treat of summer.  Whether grilled, roasted, boiled or steamed they serve as a blank canvas waiting for creativity.  They may be the most versatile of all vegetables and certainly a favorite of many.


That said, today I am featuring a twist on the old picnic classic, potato salad.  Looking for a recipe that would excite my taste buds, I found this while perusing a cooking magazine.  A weakness for a runny egg and a lover of mustard, the idea of pairing them with the new potato made me drool.  It was as if egg salad and potato salad got married with grainy mustard officiating.

Here is how it goes down.IMG_9195


8 Servings                  

Recipe adapted from Bon Appetit Magazine/ June 2015

2 ½ lb. new or baby Yukon gold or red potatoes, scrubbed

4 large eggs, room temperature

1 t mustard seeds

3T apple cider vinegar

2T whole grain mustard

1t honey

1/3 c extra virgin olive oil

Sea salt & freshly ground black pepper

1 c parsley leaves with tender stems, chopped

3T coarsely chopped dill pickles or cornichons, halved

2T fresh chives, snipped

  1. Steam potatoes, covered in a steamer basket set in a large pot over boiling water until tender, 20-30 minutes, depending on size. Transfer to a plate and allow to cool.
  2. Meanwhile cook eggs by bringing water to a boil in a large saucepan and gently lowering the eggs into it. Cook for 7 minutes. Transfer eggs to a bowl of ice water and chill until cold. Drain and peel; set aside.
  3. Toast the mustard seeds in a small dry skillet over medium-low heat, tossing constantly until seeds start to pop, about 1 minute. Transfer to a small bowl (have it ready so you can work quickly).
  4. Whisk vinegar, mustard, and honey in a large bowl. Whisking constantly, gradually add the olive oil and continue whisking until emulsified. Season with salt and pepper and set aside 3T for drizzling at the end.
  5. Halve potatoes and add to the bowl with the remaining vinaigrette. Add parsley and toss to coat, season with salt and pepper, toss again and transfer to a large bowl or platter. Halve the eggs and tuck into the potatoes. Drizzle with the reserved 3T of vinaigrette.
  6. Top with pickles, chives and toasted mustard seeds.

Do ahead: Eggs can be cooked a day ahead; drain, cover and refrigerate. Peel just before serving. Vinaigrette can be made 3 days ahead; cover and chill.

Note: If runny yolks are not your thing, cook the eggs 1-3 minutes longer for a yolk that is more set.


Perfectly balanced with the tartness of the mustard and pickle against the creaminess of the egg and potato, this salad has been making an appearance on my picnic table all season.  I love the challenge of updating the standards and have found this a perfect substitute to the mayonnaise version we have seen for oh so long.  Sometimes the same old same old has to get a facelift.

If you are one that resists change I urge you to bust out and give those baby potatoes a star role at your next summer gathering.  The do ahead tips make it perfect for any meal when time is of the essence.  For many of us that is every meal.  Right?

IMG_2584With August presenting itself yesterday, we are sadly reminded that there is only one official month of summer remaining.  You better take advantage and plan that cookout or picnic quickly.  Don’t forget to invite the season’s bounty and keep spreading the love, one side dish at a time.  The farmers markets are bursting at the seams right now making it the perfect time to support local growers.  Until next time, sending love to the farmers and to all of you.  Jeanne


6 responses to “Potato Salad Makeover

  1. Jeanne… hear, hear for make ahead (or most of it) “sides”… a biggie in my “pic-a-nic basket” too! Summer may be fleeting, but flavor isn’t! (This sounds like a year-round salad to be enjoyed… I LOVE mustard.) Thanks for your perspectives and faves from the famers’ markets, too. Yes ma’am! (And no more “over cooked” sweet corn!) Blessings to you ‘n’ yours.

    • Thank you Kim for your comments. I will be making this recipe year round as well. Grilled some sweet corn tonight YUM! You and I could plan a fabulous picnic. Come visit! Hope your summer is bringing you joy. Love, Jeanne

  2. Yum! Just made potato salad this weekend…I should of talked to your first. I also like to use eggs in mine for flavor, texture and added protein. Next time I will try your vinagarette. Thanks.

  3. This is a really good recipe, Sarah. Let me know if you try it. Hope all is well out west. Sending love to all.

  4. Elizabeth Palmer

    A perfect way to enjoy the new potatoes available now. Reminiscent of a Salad Nicoise, too; just add green beans and tuna! I’m in denial about the waning days of summer; here’s hoping for a mild autumn in WI!

    • Salad Nicoise is one of my favorite things to make and eat! For some reason the similarities went unnoticed until you mentioned it. I may have to add the beans and tuna next time. Thanks. I too am hoping for a long fall with many lazy calm days to come. Thanks as always for your remarks. Best wishes, Jeanne

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s